Logotype The Swedish National Audit Office, link to start page.

Teleworking at central government agencies

(RiR 2024:20)

Summary

The COVID-19 pandemic brought about a change in the prevalence of telework at central government agencies. Compared to the time before the pandemic, more government agencies offer their employees the opportunity to telework. In 2023, about 60% of central government employees worked from home at least some day a week. Among government agencies that offer telework, employees are most typically able to work remotely for about 20–60% of their working time. This means that many employees work alternately at the agency’s premises and remotely. The Swedish National Audit Office has examined whether central government handling of employees’ opportunity to telework contributes to the efficient performance of the government agencies’ activities.

The Swedish National Audit Office’s overall assessment is that the employees’ possibility to work remotely has not had any significant impact on whether the agencies’ activities are conducted efficiently. The audit shows that teleworking does not affect the performance of most government agencies, either positively or negatively. However, it is important to point out that this may be because it is difficult to isolate the actual effects of teleworking in the agency’s performance. Teleworking has had some positive consequences for government agencies’ activities, for example regarding conditions for recruiting and retaining staff, as well as employees’ perceived health and satisfaction.

However, at several government agencies, other aspects of the work environment, such as social interaction between employees and conditions for cooperation within the agency, have been adversely affected. These aspects are essential conditions to enable government agencies to achieve expected results. The challenges posed by telework therefore need to be addressed by the government agencies concerned to ensure that agencies’ efficiency can also be maintained and developed in the longer term. The Government needs to monitor that the challenges identified by the Swedish National Audit Office are being addressed, to ensure that they do not adversely affect the efficiency of the government agencies going forward.

Most government agencies estimate that the possibility for their employees to work remotely does not lead to any improvements or deterioration of the agency’s performance, on a general level.

More than one-third of the government agencies state that telework has had a positive effect in some areas. Government agencies report that telework has led to efficiency gains, as it has been conducive to the development of digital ways of working. It has also resulted in more time to focus, less travel and, in some cases more efficient meetings and coordination using digital tools. The few government agencies that report adverse effects on parts of their activities highlight, in particular, negative consequences on social interaction.

Employees also do not feel that telework adversely affects their performance, but that they perform equally well or slightly better when working remotely. Managers with staff responsibility experience some challenges in managing and following up their activities, but not to such a degree to have affected performance thus far.

The possibility to telework has had a positive effect on employees’ perceived job satisfaction and health, including through greater flexibility and more influence on their own work situation. These aspects contribute to government agencies’ employees increased well-being and job satisfaction. Most government agencies report that the opportunity to offer telework has made it easier to recruit and retain staff.

The largest challenges facing government agencies are related to cooperation and social interaction in the workplace. The audit shows that aspects such as social relationships and knowledge exchange among colleagues, induction of new employees and the sense of community within the government agency have been adversely affected for many agencies. Managers’ capacity to fulfil their work environment responsibilities has also been adversely affected in some respects. For example, managers with staff responsibility may find it more difficult to recognise their employees’ needs for support, because spontaneous contacts with employees have declined.

It is the assessment of the Swedish National Audit Office that on the whole, the government agencies have appropriately applied and monitored the opportunity of teleworking. For example, the government agencies have taken various measures to counteract negative consequences of teleworking, such as measures to strengthen the sense of community and leadership. The government agencies have also had sound support from the Swedish Agency for Government Employers on how to design and apply conditions for teleworking. The Government has primarily followed up the consequences of teleworking as an employer policy issue in agency dialogues.

Nevertheless, the Swedish National Audit Office has identified a number of common challenges that risk having adverse effects on government agencies’ performance in the long term. Therefore, there is reason to continue to monitor how telework is applied in central government agencies and the consequences on agencies’ performance and work environment.

Recommendations

In its audit, the Swedish National Audit Office has identified challenges that recur among most government agencies. The Swedish National Audit Office therefore makes its recommendations to the Government and the Swedish Agency for Government Employers rather than to individual government agencies. Although government agencies are largely responsible for employer policy, the Government has an overall responsibility to the Riksdag for the focus, scope and efficiency of central government activities. The Government must also follow up and report on the development in central government employer policy to the Riksdag. The Swedish Agency for Government Employers has an overarching remit to support its member agencies in employer policy issues.

The Swedish National Audit Office recommends that the Government assign the appropriate government agency the task of following up government agencies’ application of telework, preferably in a few years’ time to examine whether the situation has changed. The follow-up should particularly focus on:

  • whether teleworking has affected government agencies’ performance, positively and negatively, in the longer term
  • what measures government agencies have taken in relation to the aspects adversely affected by teleworking
  • what measures government agencies have taken to ensure that the conditions applied to teleworking are adapted to the needs of the activities
  • what measures government agencies have taken to tackle the implications of telework regarding practical circumstances, such as digital tools and premises.

The Swedish National Audit Office recommends that the Swedish Agency for Government Employers, in the support they provide to its members, continue to promote the exchange of experience and the dissemination of good examples of how the challenges of telework can be addressed.